War From Cyber Space - Richard Clarke

Image via Wikipedia

The National Interest online's article by Richard Clarke outlines the difficulties in of countries in protecting their economies from disruption of processing data that manages the controls of the nations power grid, fuel supply, or food supply chains, etc... or the ability for private commerce to perform business.

Although the article concentrates on the United States economy, it is a concern world wide that the electronic infrastructure that controls physical and logical stability of nations is fragile and vulnerable and that our systems are complex and perhaps too overly complex.

There is real concern that between nations that having the superiority to disable the other nations ability to perform commerce or defend it's controls on infrastructure that supplies services to it's citizens in times of political or resource conflict is way too much of an advantage, and then there is as Richard Clarke points out the "who dun it" piece.

Although I don't necessarily think that this is limited to cyber warfare, certainly in conventional warfare through covert activities groups have tried to blame conflicts on others not involved to escalate hostility between factions already at odds with each other.

As in the recent denial of service attacks in July, was it really who we thought it was or was it some one else trying to make it look like that. It is always not the recent notification or alert that may allow you to traverse an incident but being able to perform historical correlation on transactions that were allowed through trust environments.

The other point is although not discussed, usually, where are all the electronics made? Who makes all the components inside the equipment?

Richard Clarke -
"The major differences between cyber war and conventional war--one that makes the battlefield more perilous--is what cyber warriors call "the attribution problem." Put more simply, it is a matter of whodunit. In cyberspace, attackers can hide their identity, cover their tracks. Worse, they may be able to mislead, placing blame on others by spoofing the source."

"The "critical infrastructure" of the transportation, finance, energy and communications sectors are owned and operated by nongovernmental entities, corporations that have proven highly resistant to regulation. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) issued new cybersecurity guidelines to U.S. power companies in January 2008, requiring greater separation of the operations systems from the public Internet."

Richard Clarke was special adviser to the president for cybersecurity in the George W. Bush administration. He is now chairman of Good Harbor Consulting. His book Cyber War, coauthored with Robert Knake, will be published by HarperCollins in the spring.

National Interest Article on War from Cyber Space